{
  "checkedAt": "2026-10-22T07:02:56.382658+00:00",
  "classification": "CLI-constrained skill-text pilot, not original skill workflows",
  "conditions": [
    {
      "name": "baseline",
      "fullSkillTextFoundInFirstSystem": {},
      "skillHashes": {},
      "toolCalls": 31,
      "toolNameCounts": {
        "terminal": 21,
        "write_file": 9,
        "patch": 1
      },
      "terminalCalls": 21,
      "observedCommandCounts": {
        "designGuide": 0,
        "specGuide": 0,
        "stagedCheck": 0,
        "createFromSpec": 0,
        "createFromOps": 4,
        "genofficeAudit": 4,
        "genofficeRender": 0,
        "libreOfficeRender": 2,
        "claudeValidate": 0,
        "markitdown": 0,
        "pptxgenjsExecution": 0
      },
      "modelImageInputPartsAcrossRequests": 0,
      "trace": {
        "id": "98d089c7ba2d7bd152b7e03b39068326",
        "environment": "hermes-migration-validation",
        "timestamp": "2026-10-22T06:08:11.938Z",
        "totalCost": 0.08920368,
        "condition": "baseline",
        "observations": 32,
        "checkedAt": "2026-10-22T07:00:47.569452+00:00"
      }
    },
    {
      "name": "genoffice",
      "fullSkillTextFoundInFirstSystem": {
        "genoffice": true
      },
      "skillHashes": {
        "genoffice": "fb61206b7b60fa901f0cdfb9286d066b0a77bab927b3ac4686598f17ee864e55"
      },
      "toolCalls": 9,
      "toolNameCounts": {
        "terminal": 9
      },
      "terminalCalls": 9,
      "observedCommandCounts": {
        "designGuide": 0,
        "specGuide": 0,
        "stagedCheck": 0,
        "createFromSpec": 0,
        "createFromOps": 1,
        "genofficeAudit": 1,
        "genofficeRender": 1,
        "libreOfficeRender": 0,
        "claudeValidate": 0,
        "markitdown": 0,
        "pptxgenjsExecution": 0
      },
      "modelImageInputPartsAcrossRequests": 0,
      "trace": {
        "id": "a1d31eff66fc816272a12b0d5735a78a",
        "environment": "hermes-migration-validation",
        "timestamp": "2026-10-22T06:08:11.952Z",
        "totalCost": 0.03941757,
        "condition": "genoffice",
        "observations": 10,
        "checkedAt": "2026-10-22T07:00:46.791462+00:00"
      }
    },
    {
      "name": "genoffice-claude",
      "fullSkillTextFoundInFirstSystem": {
        "genoffice": true,
        "claude": true
      },
      "skillHashes": {
        "genoffice": "fb61206b7b60fa901f0cdfb9286d066b0a77bab927b3ac4686598f17ee864e55",
        "claude": "a7ff03e2c85b636f55232a6b1555f5dd90216b7a1a359ab289d8364e6acbc6a0"
      },
      "toolCalls": 17,
      "toolNameCounts": {
        "terminal": 13,
        "write_file": 4
      },
      "terminalCalls": 13,
      "observedCommandCounts": {
        "designGuide": 0,
        "specGuide": 0,
        "stagedCheck": 0,
        "createFromSpec": 0,
        "createFromOps": 2,
        "genofficeAudit": 1,
        "genofficeRender": 1,
        "libreOfficeRender": 2,
        "claudeValidate": 0,
        "markitdown": 0,
        "pptxgenjsExecution": 0
      },
      "modelImageInputPartsAcrossRequests": 0,
      "trace": {
        "id": "f798bf55f7d949ec648e536332fe039e",
        "environment": "hermes-migration-validation",
        "timestamp": "2026-10-22T06:08:11.888Z",
        "totalCost": 0.09892677,
        "condition": "genoffice-claude",
        "observations": 18,
        "checkedAt": "2026-10-22T07:00:48.618713+00:00"
      }
    },
    {
      "name": "claude",
      "fullSkillTextFoundInFirstSystem": {
        "claude": true
      },
      "skillHashes": {
        "claude": "a7ff03e2c85b636f55232a6b1555f5dd90216b7a1a359ab289d8364e6acbc6a0"
      },
      "toolCalls": 31,
      "toolNameCounts": {
        "terminal": 31
      },
      "terminalCalls": 31,
      "observedCommandCounts": {
        "designGuide": 0,
        "specGuide": 0,
        "stagedCheck": 0,
        "createFromSpec": 0,
        "createFromOps": 13,
        "genofficeAudit": 0,
        "genofficeRender": 0,
        "libreOfficeRender": 0,
        "claudeValidate": 0,
        "markitdown": 0,
        "pptxgenjsExecution": 0
      },
      "modelImageInputPartsAcrossRequests": 0,
      "trace": {
        "id": "12e8c184ed0fd24baf4262a1849c4252",
        "environment": "hermes-migration-validation",
        "timestamp": "2026-10-22T06:08:11.881Z",
        "totalCost": 0.256914675,
        "condition": "claude",
        "observations": 32,
        "checkedAt": "2026-10-22T07:00:48.560319+00:00"
      }
    }
  ],
  "findings": [
    "Both complete SKILL.md texts were transmitted in the applicable conditions; native skill discovery/loading was bypassed.",
    "The common prompt prohibited the GenOffice staged design workflow and Claude PptxGenJS authoring.",
    "The common task fixed a white/navy/teal palette, typography, slide count and native chart/table requirements.",
    "Claude validate.py was not invoked. GenOffice audit ran in baseline, GenOffice and combined; not Claude-only.",
    "No image input parts were transmitted to the generation model in any condition. External evaluator rendering is separate from model visual QA.",
    "GenOffice render was attempted in GenOffice and combined, and failed with app_crashed / spawn /opt/genoffice EACCES.",
    "The combined run initially used a wrong relative Claude script path, then found and executed the installed absolute path. The script bundle was present."
  ]
}